Terrestrial eDNA survey outperforms conventional approach for detecting an invasive pest insect within an agricultural ecosystem

Abstract Recent methodological advances permit surveys for terrestrial insects from the direct collection of environmental DNA (eDNA) deposited on vegetation or other surfaces. However, in contrast to well‐studied aquatic applications, little is known about how detection rates for such terrestrial e...

Descripción completa

Guardado en:

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales:	Michael C. Allen, Anne L. Nielsen, Donnie L. Peterson, Julie L. Lockwood
Formato:	article
Lenguaje:	EN
Publicado:	Wiley 2021
Materias:	biosecurity detection probability early detection insects invasive species Lycorma delicatula Environmental sciences GE1-350 Microbial ecology QR100-130
Acceso en línea:	https://doaj.org/article/16347d7078dd41ed90f0c998aba8671c
Etiquetas:	Agregar Etiqueta Sin Etiquetas, Sea el primero en etiquetar este registro!

id	oai:doaj.org-article:16347d7078dd41ed90f0c998aba8671c
record_format	dspace
spelling	oai:doaj.org-article:16347d7078dd41ed90f0c998aba8671c2021-11-23T16:15:24ZTerrestrial eDNA survey outperforms conventional approach for detecting an invasive pest insect within an agricultural ecosystem2637-494310.1002/edn3.231https://doaj.org/article/16347d7078dd41ed90f0c998aba8671c2021-11-01T00:00:00Zhttps://doi.org/10.1002/edn3.231https://doaj.org/toc/2637-4943Abstract Recent methodological advances permit surveys for terrestrial insects from the direct collection of environmental DNA (eDNA) deposited on vegetation or other surfaces. However, in contrast to well‐studied aquatic applications, little is known about how detection rates for such terrestrial eDNA‐based surveys compare with conventional survey methods. Lycorma delicatula, the spotted lanternfly, is an emerging invasive insect in eastern North America, and a significant ecological and economic pest of forested and agricultural systems, especially grapes. During fall 2019, we conducted two rounds of paired eDNA and visual surveys for spotted lanternflies within 48 plots at 12 vineyards in New Jersey, USA. We compared detection probabilities within a multimethod occupancy modeling framework and used the results to extrapolate and inform survey design. The probability of detecting spotted lanternflies given presence in a plot was over two times higher for eDNA (84%) versus visual surveys (36%). In mid‐September, lanternfly eDNA was detected at five plots in three vineyards, while visual surveys revealed only a single individual in one plot. In early October, after dispersal of lanternflies into vineyards, lanternfly eDNA was detected in 12 plots within six vineyards compared with visual detections in six plots in two vineyards. Extrapolations based on detection and local‐scale occupancy rates indicate that only five and 12 plots would have been needed to positively detect lanternfly presence with 95% confidence using eDNA in contrast to 14 and 29 plots with visual surveys alone, respective to survey rounds. Log‐linear models revealed that visual counts of lanternflies were positively related to eDNA concentrations (R2 = 71%). We provide some of the first quantitative evidence to support the enhanced sensitivity of terrestrial eDNA approaches compared with conventional methods. Such methods can augment efforts to combat invasive species through improved ability to delimit invasion fronts, identify satellite populations, and confirm local eradications.Michael C. AllenAnne L. NielsenDonnie L. PetersonJulie L. LockwoodWileyarticlebiosecuritydetection probabilityearly detectioninsectsinvasive speciesLycorma delicatulaEnvironmental sciencesGE1-350Microbial ecologyQR100-130ENEnvironmental DNA, Vol 3, Iss 6, Pp 1102-1112 (2021)
institution	DOAJ
collection	DOAJ
language	EN
topic	biosecurity detection probability early detection insects invasive species Lycorma delicatula Environmental sciences GE1-350 Microbial ecology QR100-130
spellingShingle	biosecurity detection probability early detection insects invasive species Lycorma delicatula Environmental sciences GE1-350 Microbial ecology QR100-130 Michael C. Allen Anne L. Nielsen Donnie L. Peterson Julie L. Lockwood Terrestrial eDNA survey outperforms conventional approach for detecting an invasive pest insect within an agricultural ecosystem
description	Abstract Recent methodological advances permit surveys for terrestrial insects from the direct collection of environmental DNA (eDNA) deposited on vegetation or other surfaces. However, in contrast to well‐studied aquatic applications, little is known about how detection rates for such terrestrial eDNA‐based surveys compare with conventional survey methods. Lycorma delicatula, the spotted lanternfly, is an emerging invasive insect in eastern North America, and a significant ecological and economic pest of forested and agricultural systems, especially grapes. During fall 2019, we conducted two rounds of paired eDNA and visual surveys for spotted lanternflies within 48 plots at 12 vineyards in New Jersey, USA. We compared detection probabilities within a multimethod occupancy modeling framework and used the results to extrapolate and inform survey design. The probability of detecting spotted lanternflies given presence in a plot was over two times higher for eDNA (84%) versus visual surveys (36%). In mid‐September, lanternfly eDNA was detected at five plots in three vineyards, while visual surveys revealed only a single individual in one plot. In early October, after dispersal of lanternflies into vineyards, lanternfly eDNA was detected in 12 plots within six vineyards compared with visual detections in six plots in two vineyards. Extrapolations based on detection and local‐scale occupancy rates indicate that only five and 12 plots would have been needed to positively detect lanternfly presence with 95% confidence using eDNA in contrast to 14 and 29 plots with visual surveys alone, respective to survey rounds. Log‐linear models revealed that visual counts of lanternflies were positively related to eDNA concentrations (R2 = 71%). We provide some of the first quantitative evidence to support the enhanced sensitivity of terrestrial eDNA approaches compared with conventional methods. Such methods can augment efforts to combat invasive species through improved ability to delimit invasion fronts, identify satellite populations, and confirm local eradications.
format	article
author	Michael C. Allen Anne L. Nielsen Donnie L. Peterson Julie L. Lockwood
author_facet	Michael C. Allen Anne L. Nielsen Donnie L. Peterson Julie L. Lockwood
author_sort	Michael C. Allen
title	Terrestrial eDNA survey outperforms conventional approach for detecting an invasive pest insect within an agricultural ecosystem
title_short	Terrestrial eDNA survey outperforms conventional approach for detecting an invasive pest insect within an agricultural ecosystem
title_full	Terrestrial eDNA survey outperforms conventional approach for detecting an invasive pest insect within an agricultural ecosystem
title_fullStr	Terrestrial eDNA survey outperforms conventional approach for detecting an invasive pest insect within an agricultural ecosystem
title_full_unstemmed	Terrestrial eDNA survey outperforms conventional approach for detecting an invasive pest insect within an agricultural ecosystem
title_sort	terrestrial edna survey outperforms conventional approach for detecting an invasive pest insect within an agricultural ecosystem
publisher	Wiley
publishDate	2021
url	https://doaj.org/article/16347d7078dd41ed90f0c998aba8671c
work_keys_str_mv	AT michaelcallen terrestrialednasurveyoutperformsconventionalapproachfordetectinganinvasivepestinsectwithinanagriculturalecosystem AT annelnielsen terrestrialednasurveyoutperformsconventionalapproachfordetectinganinvasivepestinsectwithinanagriculturalecosystem AT donnielpeterson terrestrialednasurveyoutperformsconventionalapproachfordetectinganinvasivepestinsectwithinanagriculturalecosystem AT juliellockwood terrestrialednasurveyoutperformsconventionalapproachfordetectinganinvasivepestinsectwithinanagriculturalecosystem
_version_	1718416196701782016

Terrestrial eDNA survey outperforms conventional approach for detecting an invasive pest insect within an agricultural ecosystem

Ejemplares similares