Terrestrial mesopredators did not increase after top-predator removal in a large-scale experimental test of mesopredator release theory

Abstract Removal or loss of top-predators has been predicted to cause cascading negative effects for ecosystems, including mesopredator release. However, reliable evidence for these processes in terrestrial systems has been mixed and equivocal due, in large part, to the systemic and continued use of...

Descripción completa

Guardado en:

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales:	Geoff Castle, Deane Smith, Lee R. Allen, Benjamin L. Allen
Formato:	article
Lenguaje:	EN
Publicado:	Nature Portfolio 2021
Materias:	Medicine R Science Q
Acceso en línea:	https://doaj.org/article/7f2b9834dcf6417bbde1edacbe95c876
Etiquetas:	Agregar Etiqueta Sin Etiquetas, Sea el primero en etiquetar este registro!

id	oai:doaj.org-article:7f2b9834dcf6417bbde1edacbe95c876
record_format	dspace
spelling	oai:doaj.org-article:7f2b9834dcf6417bbde1edacbe95c8762021-12-02T17:23:47ZTerrestrial mesopredators did not increase after top-predator removal in a large-scale experimental test of mesopredator release theory10.1038/s41598-021-97634-42045-2322https://doaj.org/article/7f2b9834dcf6417bbde1edacbe95c8762021-09-01T00:00:00Zhttps://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-97634-4https://doaj.org/toc/2045-2322Abstract Removal or loss of top-predators has been predicted to cause cascading negative effects for ecosystems, including mesopredator release. However, reliable evidence for these processes in terrestrial systems has been mixed and equivocal due, in large part, to the systemic and continued use of low-inference study designs to investigate this issue. Even previous large-scale manipulative experiments of strong inferential value have been limited by experimental design features (i.e. failure to prevent migration between treatments) that constrain possible inferences about the presence or absence of mesopredator release effects. Here, we build on these previous strong-inference experiments and report the outcomes of additional large-scale manipulative experiments to eradicate Australian dingoes from two fenced areas where dingo migration was restricted and where theory would predict an increase in extant European red foxes, feral cats and goannas. We demonstrate the removal and suppression of dingoes to undetectable levels over 4–5 years with no corresponding increases in mesopredator relative abundances, which remained low and stable throughout the experiment at both sites. We further demonstrate widespread absence of negative relationships between predators, indicating that the mechanism underpinning predicted mesopredator releases was not present. Our results are consistent with all previous large-scale manipulative experiments and long-term mensurative studies which collectively demonstrate that (1) dingoes do not suppress red foxes, feral cats or goannas at the population level, (2) repeated, temporary suppression of dingoes in open systems does not create mesopredator release effects, and (3) removal and sustained suppression of dingoes to undetectable levels in closed systems does not create mesopredator release effects either. Our experiments add to similar reports from North America, Asia, Europe and southern Africa which indicate that not only is there a widespread absence of reliable evidence for these processes, but there is also a large and continually growing body of experimental evidence of absence for these processes in many terrestrial systems. We conclude that although sympatric predators may interact negatively with each other on smaller spatiotemporal scales, that these negative interactions do not always scale-up to the population level, nor are they always strong enough to create mesopredator suppression or release effects.Geoff CastleDeane SmithLee R. AllenBenjamin L. AllenNature PortfolioarticleMedicineRScienceQENScientific Reports, Vol 11, Iss 1, Pp 1-18 (2021)
institution	DOAJ
collection	DOAJ
language	EN
topic	Medicine R Science Q
spellingShingle	Medicine R Science Q Geoff Castle Deane Smith Lee R. Allen Benjamin L. Allen Terrestrial mesopredators did not increase after top-predator removal in a large-scale experimental test of mesopredator release theory
description	Abstract Removal or loss of top-predators has been predicted to cause cascading negative effects for ecosystems, including mesopredator release. However, reliable evidence for these processes in terrestrial systems has been mixed and equivocal due, in large part, to the systemic and continued use of low-inference study designs to investigate this issue. Even previous large-scale manipulative experiments of strong inferential value have been limited by experimental design features (i.e. failure to prevent migration between treatments) that constrain possible inferences about the presence or absence of mesopredator release effects. Here, we build on these previous strong-inference experiments and report the outcomes of additional large-scale manipulative experiments to eradicate Australian dingoes from two fenced areas where dingo migration was restricted and where theory would predict an increase in extant European red foxes, feral cats and goannas. We demonstrate the removal and suppression of dingoes to undetectable levels over 4–5 years with no corresponding increases in mesopredator relative abundances, which remained low and stable throughout the experiment at both sites. We further demonstrate widespread absence of negative relationships between predators, indicating that the mechanism underpinning predicted mesopredator releases was not present. Our results are consistent with all previous large-scale manipulative experiments and long-term mensurative studies which collectively demonstrate that (1) dingoes do not suppress red foxes, feral cats or goannas at the population level, (2) repeated, temporary suppression of dingoes in open systems does not create mesopredator release effects, and (3) removal and sustained suppression of dingoes to undetectable levels in closed systems does not create mesopredator release effects either. Our experiments add to similar reports from North America, Asia, Europe and southern Africa which indicate that not only is there a widespread absence of reliable evidence for these processes, but there is also a large and continually growing body of experimental evidence of absence for these processes in many terrestrial systems. We conclude that although sympatric predators may interact negatively with each other on smaller spatiotemporal scales, that these negative interactions do not always scale-up to the population level, nor are they always strong enough to create mesopredator suppression or release effects.
format	article
author	Geoff Castle Deane Smith Lee R. Allen Benjamin L. Allen
author_facet	Geoff Castle Deane Smith Lee R. Allen Benjamin L. Allen
author_sort	Geoff Castle
title	Terrestrial mesopredators did not increase after top-predator removal in a large-scale experimental test of mesopredator release theory
title_short	Terrestrial mesopredators did not increase after top-predator removal in a large-scale experimental test of mesopredator release theory
title_full	Terrestrial mesopredators did not increase after top-predator removal in a large-scale experimental test of mesopredator release theory
title_fullStr	Terrestrial mesopredators did not increase after top-predator removal in a large-scale experimental test of mesopredator release theory
title_full_unstemmed	Terrestrial mesopredators did not increase after top-predator removal in a large-scale experimental test of mesopredator release theory
title_sort	terrestrial mesopredators did not increase after top-predator removal in a large-scale experimental test of mesopredator release theory
publisher	Nature Portfolio
publishDate	2021
url	https://doaj.org/article/7f2b9834dcf6417bbde1edacbe95c876
work_keys_str_mv	AT geoffcastle terrestrialmesopredatorsdidnotincreaseaftertoppredatorremovalinalargescaleexperimentaltestofmesopredatorreleasetheory AT deanesmith terrestrialmesopredatorsdidnotincreaseaftertoppredatorremovalinalargescaleexperimentaltestofmesopredatorreleasetheory AT leerallen terrestrialmesopredatorsdidnotincreaseaftertoppredatorremovalinalargescaleexperimentaltestofmesopredatorreleasetheory AT benjaminlallen terrestrialmesopredatorsdidnotincreaseaftertoppredatorremovalinalargescaleexperimentaltestofmesopredatorreleasetheory
_version_	1718380979439009792

Terrestrial mesopredators did not increase after top-predator removal in a large-scale experimental test of mesopredator release theory

Ejemplares similares