"Endless Forms" of Evolution? Heuristics in Darwin and Taine.

Morse Peckham wrote in 1959 that rejection and misinterpretation had characterised the first one hundred years of Darwinism. After reviewing René Wellek's 1956 survey of evolutionary ideas in literary history and Joseph Carroll's 1995 discussion of Darwinism in Hippolyte Taine, I argue tha...

Descripción completa

Guardado en:

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autor principal:	Andrew Court
Formato:	article
Lenguaje:	EN
Publicado:	University of Edinburgh 2006
Materias:	Fine Arts N Language and Literature P
Acceso en línea:	https://doaj.org/article/8dcde81e5f5c4599b2e6673ef9226e20
Etiquetas:	Agregar Etiqueta Sin Etiquetas, Sea el primero en etiquetar este registro!

id	oai:doaj.org-article:8dcde81e5f5c4599b2e6673ef9226e20
record_format	dspace
spelling	oai:doaj.org-article:8dcde81e5f5c4599b2e6673ef9226e202021-11-23T09:46:01Z"Endless Forms" of Evolution? Heuristics in Darwin and Taine.1749-9771https://doaj.org/article/8dcde81e5f5c4599b2e6673ef9226e202006-08-01T00:00:00Zhttp://www.forumjournal.org/article/view/560https://doaj.org/toc/1749-9771Morse Peckham wrote in 1959 that rejection and misinterpretation had characterised the first one hundred years of Darwinism. After reviewing René Wellek's 1956 survey of evolutionary ideas in literary history and Joseph Carroll's 1995 discussion of Darwinism in Hippolyte Taine, I argue that Wellek and Carroll have failed to provide accurate accounts of Darwin's influence. I suggest that methodological parallels must be found to make a claim for a theoretical approach being "Darwinian." I consider why The Origin of Species might have appealed methodologically to Taine by examining Darwin's argument, and then suggest that there is a better evaluative criterion of influence—that of "heuristic support"—than those provided by Wellek or Carroll. I test the hypothesis that the "shape" of Taine's theory in History of English Literature is the same as that of Darwin's theory in the Origin. I summarise Taine's theory in brief outline, counter Carroll's claim that Taine was a "biological determinist," and show that Taine's theory was congruent at the explanatory, methodological level with Darwin's, finding that Taine used the same kind of heuristic support to overcome procedural problems similar to Darwin's. I conclude that literary scholars must make better use of specialist scholarship in history and philosophy of science to answer Peckham's charge.Andrew CourtUniversity of EdinburgharticleFine ArtsNLanguage and LiteraturePENForum (2006)
institution	DOAJ
collection	DOAJ
language	EN
topic	Fine Arts N Language and Literature P
spellingShingle	Fine Arts N Language and Literature P Andrew Court "Endless Forms" of Evolution? Heuristics in Darwin and Taine.
description	Morse Peckham wrote in 1959 that rejection and misinterpretation had characterised the first one hundred years of Darwinism. After reviewing René Wellek's 1956 survey of evolutionary ideas in literary history and Joseph Carroll's 1995 discussion of Darwinism in Hippolyte Taine, I argue that Wellek and Carroll have failed to provide accurate accounts of Darwin's influence. I suggest that methodological parallels must be found to make a claim for a theoretical approach being "Darwinian." I consider why The Origin of Species might have appealed methodologically to Taine by examining Darwin's argument, and then suggest that there is a better evaluative criterion of influence—that of "heuristic support"—than those provided by Wellek or Carroll. I test the hypothesis that the "shape" of Taine's theory in History of English Literature is the same as that of Darwin's theory in the Origin. I summarise Taine's theory in brief outline, counter Carroll's claim that Taine was a "biological determinist," and show that Taine's theory was congruent at the explanatory, methodological level with Darwin's, finding that Taine used the same kind of heuristic support to overcome procedural problems similar to Darwin's. I conclude that literary scholars must make better use of specialist scholarship in history and philosophy of science to answer Peckham's charge.
format	article
author	Andrew Court
author_facet	Andrew Court
author_sort	Andrew Court
title	"Endless Forms" of Evolution? Heuristics in Darwin and Taine.
title_short	"Endless Forms" of Evolution? Heuristics in Darwin and Taine.
title_full	"Endless Forms" of Evolution? Heuristics in Darwin and Taine.
title_fullStr	"Endless Forms" of Evolution? Heuristics in Darwin and Taine.
title_full_unstemmed	"Endless Forms" of Evolution? Heuristics in Darwin and Taine.
title_sort	"endless forms" of evolution? heuristics in darwin and taine.
publisher	University of Edinburgh
publishDate	2006
url	https://doaj.org/article/8dcde81e5f5c4599b2e6673ef9226e20
work_keys_str_mv	AT andrewcourt endlessformsofevolutionheuristicsindarwinandtaine
_version_	1718416777932701696

"Endless Forms" of Evolution? Heuristics in Darwin and Taine.

Ejemplares similares