Return of individual research results: What do participants prefer and expect?

Newer data platforms offer increased opportunity to share multidimensional health data with research participants, but the preferences of participants for which data to receive and how is evolving. Our objective is to describe the preferences and expectations of participants for the return of indivi...

Descripción completa

Guardado en:
Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Sabina Sayeed, Robert Califf, Robert Green, Celeste Wong, Kenneth Mahaffey, Sanjiv Sam Gambhir, Jessica Mega, Bray Patrick-Lake, Kaylyn Frazier, Michael Pignone, Adrian Hernandez, Svati H Shah, Alice C Fan, Sarah Krüg, Terry Shaack, Scarlet Shore, Susie Spielman, Julie Eckstrand, Charlene A Wong, Project Baseline Health Study Research Group
Formato: article
Lenguaje:EN
Publicado: Public Library of Science (PLoS) 2021
Materias:
R
Q
Acceso en línea:https://doaj.org/article/a6ce915f4b6f4e77b66b271af01747a5
Etiquetas: Agregar Etiqueta
Sin Etiquetas, Sea el primero en etiquetar este registro!
id oai:doaj.org-article:a6ce915f4b6f4e77b66b271af01747a5
record_format dspace
spelling oai:doaj.org-article:a6ce915f4b6f4e77b66b271af01747a52021-12-02T20:09:00ZReturn of individual research results: What do participants prefer and expect?1932-620310.1371/journal.pone.0254153https://doaj.org/article/a6ce915f4b6f4e77b66b271af01747a52021-01-01T00:00:00Zhttps://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0254153https://doaj.org/toc/1932-6203Newer data platforms offer increased opportunity to share multidimensional health data with research participants, but the preferences of participants for which data to receive and how is evolving. Our objective is to describe the preferences and expectations of participants for the return of individual research results within Project Baseline Health Study (PBHS). The PBHS is an ongoing, multicenter, longitudinal cohort study with data from four initial enrollment sites. PBHS participants are recruited from the general population along with groups enriched for heart disease and cancer disease risk. Cross-sectional data on return of results were collected in 2017-2018 from an (1) in-person enrollment survey (n = 1,890), (2) benchmark online survey (n = 1,059), and (3) participant interviews (n = 21). The main outcomes included (1) preferences for type of information to be added next to returned results, (2) participant plans for sharing returned results with a non-study clinician, and (3) choice to opt-out of receiving genetic results. Results were compared by sociodemographic characteristics. Enrollment and benchmark survey respondents were 57.1% and 53.5% female, and 60.0% and 66.2% white, respectively. Participants preferred the following data types be added to returned results in the future: genetics (29.9%), heart imaging, (16.4%), study watch (15.8%), and microbiome (13.3%). Older adults (OR 0.60, 95% CI: 0.41-0.87) were less likely to want their genetic results returned next. Forty percent of participants reported that they would not share all returned results with their non-study clinicians. Black (OR 0.64, 95% CI 0.43-0.95) and Asian (OR 0.47, 95% CI 0.30-0.73) participants were less likely, and older participants more likely (OR 1.45-1.61), to plan to share all results with their clinician than their counterparts. At enrollment, 5.8% of participants opted out of receiving their genetics results. The study showed that substantial heterogeneity existed in participant's preferences and expectations for return of results, and variations were related to sociodemographic characteristics.Sabina SayeedRobert CaliffRobert GreenCeleste WongKenneth MahaffeySanjiv Sam GambhirJessica MegaBray Patrick-LakeKaylyn FrazierMichael PignoneAdrian HernandezSvati H ShahAlice C FanSarah KrügTerry ShaackScarlet ShoreSusie SpielmanJulie EckstrandCharlene A WongProject Baseline Health Study Research GroupPublic Library of Science (PLoS)articleMedicineRScienceQENPLoS ONE, Vol 16, Iss 7, p e0254153 (2021)
institution DOAJ
collection DOAJ
language EN
topic Medicine
R
Science
Q
spellingShingle Medicine
R
Science
Q
Sabina Sayeed
Robert Califf
Robert Green
Celeste Wong
Kenneth Mahaffey
Sanjiv Sam Gambhir
Jessica Mega
Bray Patrick-Lake
Kaylyn Frazier
Michael Pignone
Adrian Hernandez
Svati H Shah
Alice C Fan
Sarah Krüg
Terry Shaack
Scarlet Shore
Susie Spielman
Julie Eckstrand
Charlene A Wong
Project Baseline Health Study Research Group
Return of individual research results: What do participants prefer and expect?
description Newer data platforms offer increased opportunity to share multidimensional health data with research participants, but the preferences of participants for which data to receive and how is evolving. Our objective is to describe the preferences and expectations of participants for the return of individual research results within Project Baseline Health Study (PBHS). The PBHS is an ongoing, multicenter, longitudinal cohort study with data from four initial enrollment sites. PBHS participants are recruited from the general population along with groups enriched for heart disease and cancer disease risk. Cross-sectional data on return of results were collected in 2017-2018 from an (1) in-person enrollment survey (n = 1,890), (2) benchmark online survey (n = 1,059), and (3) participant interviews (n = 21). The main outcomes included (1) preferences for type of information to be added next to returned results, (2) participant plans for sharing returned results with a non-study clinician, and (3) choice to opt-out of receiving genetic results. Results were compared by sociodemographic characteristics. Enrollment and benchmark survey respondents were 57.1% and 53.5% female, and 60.0% and 66.2% white, respectively. Participants preferred the following data types be added to returned results in the future: genetics (29.9%), heart imaging, (16.4%), study watch (15.8%), and microbiome (13.3%). Older adults (OR 0.60, 95% CI: 0.41-0.87) were less likely to want their genetic results returned next. Forty percent of participants reported that they would not share all returned results with their non-study clinicians. Black (OR 0.64, 95% CI 0.43-0.95) and Asian (OR 0.47, 95% CI 0.30-0.73) participants were less likely, and older participants more likely (OR 1.45-1.61), to plan to share all results with their clinician than their counterparts. At enrollment, 5.8% of participants opted out of receiving their genetics results. The study showed that substantial heterogeneity existed in participant's preferences and expectations for return of results, and variations were related to sociodemographic characteristics.
format article
author Sabina Sayeed
Robert Califf
Robert Green
Celeste Wong
Kenneth Mahaffey
Sanjiv Sam Gambhir
Jessica Mega
Bray Patrick-Lake
Kaylyn Frazier
Michael Pignone
Adrian Hernandez
Svati H Shah
Alice C Fan
Sarah Krüg
Terry Shaack
Scarlet Shore
Susie Spielman
Julie Eckstrand
Charlene A Wong
Project Baseline Health Study Research Group
author_facet Sabina Sayeed
Robert Califf
Robert Green
Celeste Wong
Kenneth Mahaffey
Sanjiv Sam Gambhir
Jessica Mega
Bray Patrick-Lake
Kaylyn Frazier
Michael Pignone
Adrian Hernandez
Svati H Shah
Alice C Fan
Sarah Krüg
Terry Shaack
Scarlet Shore
Susie Spielman
Julie Eckstrand
Charlene A Wong
Project Baseline Health Study Research Group
author_sort Sabina Sayeed
title Return of individual research results: What do participants prefer and expect?
title_short Return of individual research results: What do participants prefer and expect?
title_full Return of individual research results: What do participants prefer and expect?
title_fullStr Return of individual research results: What do participants prefer and expect?
title_full_unstemmed Return of individual research results: What do participants prefer and expect?
title_sort return of individual research results: what do participants prefer and expect?
publisher Public Library of Science (PLoS)
publishDate 2021
url https://doaj.org/article/a6ce915f4b6f4e77b66b271af01747a5
work_keys_str_mv AT sabinasayeed returnofindividualresearchresultswhatdoparticipantspreferandexpect
AT robertcaliff returnofindividualresearchresultswhatdoparticipantspreferandexpect
AT robertgreen returnofindividualresearchresultswhatdoparticipantspreferandexpect
AT celestewong returnofindividualresearchresultswhatdoparticipantspreferandexpect
AT kennethmahaffey returnofindividualresearchresultswhatdoparticipantspreferandexpect
AT sanjivsamgambhir returnofindividualresearchresultswhatdoparticipantspreferandexpect
AT jessicamega returnofindividualresearchresultswhatdoparticipantspreferandexpect
AT braypatricklake returnofindividualresearchresultswhatdoparticipantspreferandexpect
AT kaylynfrazier returnofindividualresearchresultswhatdoparticipantspreferandexpect
AT michaelpignone returnofindividualresearchresultswhatdoparticipantspreferandexpect
AT adrianhernandez returnofindividualresearchresultswhatdoparticipantspreferandexpect
AT svatihshah returnofindividualresearchresultswhatdoparticipantspreferandexpect
AT alicecfan returnofindividualresearchresultswhatdoparticipantspreferandexpect
AT sarahkrug returnofindividualresearchresultswhatdoparticipantspreferandexpect
AT terryshaack returnofindividualresearchresultswhatdoparticipantspreferandexpect
AT scarletshore returnofindividualresearchresultswhatdoparticipantspreferandexpect
AT susiespielman returnofindividualresearchresultswhatdoparticipantspreferandexpect
AT julieeckstrand returnofindividualresearchresultswhatdoparticipantspreferandexpect
AT charleneawong returnofindividualresearchresultswhatdoparticipantspreferandexpect
AT projectbaselinehealthstudyresearchgroup returnofindividualresearchresultswhatdoparticipantspreferandexpect
_version_ 1718375141697650688