The Constitutional Limits of Government According to the Constitution's Framers

The U.S. Constitution, as understood by the men who wrote it – the Framers – authorized only a limited form of federal government: limited in what it is allowed to do. That power, in turn, can only legitimately come from the People, who created the Federal Government. The said government is merely...

Descripción completa

Guardado en:

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autor principal:	Zbigniew Mazurak
Formato:	article
Lenguaje:	EN PL
Publicado:	Ksiegarnia Akademicka Publishing 2014
Materias:	the U.S. Constitution the Framers of the Constitution Law K Political science J
Acceso en línea:	https://doaj.org/article/c3e1637b756249a6912d8943ceb0ac93
Etiquetas:	Agregar Etiqueta Sin Etiquetas, Sea el primero en etiquetar este registro!

id	oai:doaj.org-article:c3e1637b756249a6912d8943ceb0ac93
record_format	dspace
spelling	oai:doaj.org-article:c3e1637b756249a6912d8943ceb0ac932021-11-27T13:15:49ZThe Constitutional Limits of Government According to the Constitution's Framers10.12797/Politeja.11.2014.32.111733-67162391-6737https://doaj.org/article/c3e1637b756249a6912d8943ceb0ac932014-12-01T00:00:00Zhttps://journals.akademicka.pl/politeja/article/view/2420https://doaj.org/toc/1733-6716https://doaj.org/toc/2391-6737 The U.S. Constitution, as understood by the men who wrote it – the Framers – authorized only a limited form of federal government: limited in what it is allowed to do. That power, in turn, can only legitimately come from the People, who created the Federal Government. The said government is merely their creature. The objects on which it may legislate and spend money are strictly limited by its text, most notably Article I of the Constitution and the Tenth Amendment. The so‑called Interstate Commerce, General Welfare, and Necessary and Proper clauses, sometimes invoked in the contemporary news media as giving the Federal Government broad powers, are actually limited in scope and do not give it any broad powers. This is clearly demonstrated by the writings of the men who wrote the Constitution – the Framers, chiefly James Madison and Alexander Hamilton. Their writings, particularly the Federalist Papers, explain what exact objects the Federal Government’s authority is limited to, and why the claims of those who interpret the Constitution as giving the central government sweeping powers are wrong. The Necessary and Proper clause only gives the Congress the power to execute powers already granted, and does not give it any new substantive authority. The General Welfare clause (part of Clause 1 of Article I, Section 8 of the Constitution) is a general statement immediately limited and qualified by Clauses 3‑16; and in the Framers’ times, “welfare” meant only exemption from any unusual calamity and enjoyment of the ordinary blessings of society. The Interstate Commerce Clause only authorizes Congress to prevent the states from inhibiting interstate commerce – the free transportation and sale of goods and services across state borders – with barriers such as interstate tolls. Thus, the Federal Government the Framers envisaged – and created with the Constitution – was one of strictly limited, enumerated powers. This article starts from the premise that the men who wrote the Constitution knew it best and are the most credible authority on its genuine meaning. This is confirmed further by the writings of constitutional law scholars and by rulings of the Supreme Court in the Marshall era – rulings which, to this day, greatly influence American jurisprudence, and whose authors looked to the Federalist Papers for the correct interpretation of the Constitution. Zbigniew MazurakKsiegarnia Akademicka Publishingarticlethe U.S. Constitutionthe Framers of the ConstitutionLawKPolitical scienceJENPLPoliteja, Vol 11, Iss 6 (32) (2014)
institution	DOAJ
collection	DOAJ
language	EN PL
topic	the U.S. Constitution the Framers of the Constitution Law K Political science J
spellingShingle	the U.S. Constitution the Framers of the Constitution Law K Political science J Zbigniew Mazurak The Constitutional Limits of Government According to the Constitution's Framers
description	The U.S. Constitution, as understood by the men who wrote it – the Framers – authorized only a limited form of federal government: limited in what it is allowed to do. That power, in turn, can only legitimately come from the People, who created the Federal Government. The said government is merely their creature. The objects on which it may legislate and spend money are strictly limited by its text, most notably Article I of the Constitution and the Tenth Amendment. The so‑called Interstate Commerce, General Welfare, and Necessary and Proper clauses, sometimes invoked in the contemporary news media as giving the Federal Government broad powers, are actually limited in scope and do not give it any broad powers. This is clearly demonstrated by the writings of the men who wrote the Constitution – the Framers, chiefly James Madison and Alexander Hamilton. Their writings, particularly the Federalist Papers, explain what exact objects the Federal Government’s authority is limited to, and why the claims of those who interpret the Constitution as giving the central government sweeping powers are wrong. The Necessary and Proper clause only gives the Congress the power to execute powers already granted, and does not give it any new substantive authority. The General Welfare clause (part of Clause 1 of Article I, Section 8 of the Constitution) is a general statement immediately limited and qualified by Clauses 3‑16; and in the Framers’ times, “welfare” meant only exemption from any unusual calamity and enjoyment of the ordinary blessings of society. The Interstate Commerce Clause only authorizes Congress to prevent the states from inhibiting interstate commerce – the free transportation and sale of goods and services across state borders – with barriers such as interstate tolls. Thus, the Federal Government the Framers envisaged – and created with the Constitution – was one of strictly limited, enumerated powers. This article starts from the premise that the men who wrote the Constitution knew it best and are the most credible authority on its genuine meaning. This is confirmed further by the writings of constitutional law scholars and by rulings of the Supreme Court in the Marshall era – rulings which, to this day, greatly influence American jurisprudence, and whose authors looked to the Federalist Papers for the correct interpretation of the Constitution.
format	article
author	Zbigniew Mazurak
author_facet	Zbigniew Mazurak
author_sort	Zbigniew Mazurak
title	The Constitutional Limits of Government According to the Constitution's Framers
title_short	The Constitutional Limits of Government According to the Constitution's Framers
title_full	The Constitutional Limits of Government According to the Constitution's Framers
title_fullStr	The Constitutional Limits of Government According to the Constitution's Framers
title_full_unstemmed	The Constitutional Limits of Government According to the Constitution's Framers
title_sort	constitutional limits of government according to the constitution's framers
publisher	Ksiegarnia Akademicka Publishing
publishDate	2014
url	https://doaj.org/article/c3e1637b756249a6912d8943ceb0ac93
work_keys_str_mv	AT zbigniewmazurak theconstitutionallimitsofgovernmentaccordingtotheconstitutionsframers AT zbigniewmazurak constitutionallimitsofgovernmentaccordingtotheconstitutionsframers
_version_	1718408587499274240

The Constitutional Limits of Government According to the Constitution's Framers

Ejemplares similares