Évaluation du développement territorial comme processus d'innovation et d'institutionnalisation : le cas du Territoire du Alto Sertão do Piauí e Pernambuco au Nordeste du Brésil

Because of their transversal and multipurpose character, evaluation of territorial development policies cannot rely on the tools used to assess sectoral policies. Procedural issues are mainly dominant, since arrangements essentially focus on governance and coordination. In order to evaluate a proced...

Descripción completa

Guardado en:

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales:	Jean-Philippe Tonneau, Marc Piraux, Emilie Coudel, Sergio Guilherme de Azevedo
Formato:	article
Lenguaje:	FR
Publicado:	Éditions en environnement VertigO 2009
Materias:	innovation Territorial development governance arrangements collective competencies environment Environmental sciences GE1-350
Acceso en línea:	https://doaj.org/article/ca2a78f9f55042f1a898180fbae7216a
Etiquetas:	Agregar Etiqueta Sin Etiquetas, Sea el primero en etiquetar este registro!

id	oai:doaj.org-article:ca2a78f9f55042f1a898180fbae7216a
record_format	dspace
spelling	oai:doaj.org-article:ca2a78f9f55042f1a898180fbae7216a2021-12-02T10:01:21ZÉvaluation du développement territorial comme processus d'innovation et d'institutionnalisation : le cas du Territoire du Alto Sertão do Piauí e Pernambuco au Nordeste du Brésil1492-844210.4000/vertigo.9207https://doaj.org/article/ca2a78f9f55042f1a898180fbae7216a2009-12-01T00:00:00Zhttp://journals.openedition.org/vertigo/9207https://doaj.org/toc/1492-8442Because of their transversal and multipurpose character, evaluation of territorial development policies cannot rely on the tools used to assess sectoral policies. Procedural issues are mainly dominant, since arrangements essentially focus on governance and coordination. In order to evaluate a procedural approach, specifying the assessment referential is necessary. What and how evaluate ? It is the purpose of this paper, which aims to contribute to assessment methods, by analysing the impacts of a research-action to develop a "weakened" territory of the "Alto Sertão of Piaui and Pernambuco ", located in Northeast of Brazil. The objective is to characterize the processes at work, in order to understand them and to define their scope. The first part lists the expectations regarding the territorial development policies: increasing and mobilizing the human, social and institutional capitals, so as to develop adaptation and innovation capacities and improve systems of activities and governance. Territorial engineering processes must be assessed in the light of their ability to build competencies, to encourage innovation and have it recognized by the governance systems. The methods used to evaluate the experiment are then presented both qualitative and quantitative. The experiment is described in the second part of the article. Actors’s training and project elaboration were combined trough the organization of a governance forum, technical experiments and training sessions. In terms of governance, this led to the creation of a local consortium as well as a technical agency, both in charge of implementing different development actions, within a territorial project. Our goal is to give some facts on the action and its impacts. The third part discusses the insight brought by this experiment. The authors notice the ideal conditions of the experiment, and how difficult its replication turned out to be. They evaluate how the learning process contributed to the development of human, social and institutional capitals, mobilized in terms of collective skills, them alone being able to change situations by creating new development opportunities, by achieving innovation trough the construction of pragmatic rules, offering a solution to the studied issues. The conclusion analyse the evaluation criteria and the possible improvements to the methodologies developped.Jean-Philippe TonneauMarc PirauxEmilie CoudelSergio Guilherme de AzevedoÉditions en environnement VertigOarticleinnovationTerritorial developmentgovernance arrangementscollective competenciesenvironmentEnvironmental sciencesGE1-350FRVertigO, Vol 9, Iss 3 (2009)
institution	DOAJ
collection	DOAJ
language	FR
topic	innovation Territorial development governance arrangements collective competencies environment Environmental sciences GE1-350
spellingShingle	innovation Territorial development governance arrangements collective competencies environment Environmental sciences GE1-350 Jean-Philippe Tonneau Marc Piraux Emilie Coudel Sergio Guilherme de Azevedo Évaluation du développement territorial comme processus d'innovation et d'institutionnalisation : le cas du Territoire du Alto Sertão do Piauí e Pernambuco au Nordeste du Brésil
description	Because of their transversal and multipurpose character, evaluation of territorial development policies cannot rely on the tools used to assess sectoral policies. Procedural issues are mainly dominant, since arrangements essentially focus on governance and coordination. In order to evaluate a procedural approach, specifying the assessment referential is necessary. What and how evaluate ? It is the purpose of this paper, which aims to contribute to assessment methods, by analysing the impacts of a research-action to develop a "weakened" territory of the "Alto Sertão of Piaui and Pernambuco ", located in Northeast of Brazil. The objective is to characterize the processes at work, in order to understand them and to define their scope. The first part lists the expectations regarding the territorial development policies: increasing and mobilizing the human, social and institutional capitals, so as to develop adaptation and innovation capacities and improve systems of activities and governance. Territorial engineering processes must be assessed in the light of their ability to build competencies, to encourage innovation and have it recognized by the governance systems. The methods used to evaluate the experiment are then presented both qualitative and quantitative. The experiment is described in the second part of the article. Actors’s training and project elaboration were combined trough the organization of a governance forum, technical experiments and training sessions. In terms of governance, this led to the creation of a local consortium as well as a technical agency, both in charge of implementing different development actions, within a territorial project. Our goal is to give some facts on the action and its impacts. The third part discusses the insight brought by this experiment. The authors notice the ideal conditions of the experiment, and how difficult its replication turned out to be. They evaluate how the learning process contributed to the development of human, social and institutional capitals, mobilized in terms of collective skills, them alone being able to change situations by creating new development opportunities, by achieving innovation trough the construction of pragmatic rules, offering a solution to the studied issues. The conclusion analyse the evaluation criteria and the possible improvements to the methodologies developped.
format	article
author	Jean-Philippe Tonneau Marc Piraux Emilie Coudel Sergio Guilherme de Azevedo
author_facet	Jean-Philippe Tonneau Marc Piraux Emilie Coudel Sergio Guilherme de Azevedo
author_sort	Jean-Philippe Tonneau
title	Évaluation du développement territorial comme processus d'innovation et d'institutionnalisation : le cas du Territoire du Alto Sertão do Piauí e Pernambuco au Nordeste du Brésil
title_short	Évaluation du développement territorial comme processus d'innovation et d'institutionnalisation : le cas du Territoire du Alto Sertão do Piauí e Pernambuco au Nordeste du Brésil
title_full	Évaluation du développement territorial comme processus d'innovation et d'institutionnalisation : le cas du Territoire du Alto Sertão do Piauí e Pernambuco au Nordeste du Brésil
title_fullStr	Évaluation du développement territorial comme processus d'innovation et d'institutionnalisation : le cas du Territoire du Alto Sertão do Piauí e Pernambuco au Nordeste du Brésil
title_full_unstemmed	Évaluation du développement territorial comme processus d'innovation et d'institutionnalisation : le cas du Territoire du Alto Sertão do Piauí e Pernambuco au Nordeste du Brésil
title_sort	évaluation du développement territorial comme processus d'innovation et d'institutionnalisation : le cas du territoire du alto sertão do piauí e pernambuco au nordeste du brésil
publisher	Éditions en environnement VertigO
publishDate	2009
url	https://doaj.org/article/ca2a78f9f55042f1a898180fbae7216a
work_keys_str_mv	AT jeanphilippetonneau evaluationdudeveloppementterritorialcommeprocessusdinnovationetdinstitutionnalisationlecasduterritoiredualtosertaodopiauiepernambucoaunordestedubresil AT marcpiraux evaluationdudeveloppementterritorialcommeprocessusdinnovationetdinstitutionnalisationlecasduterritoiredualtosertaodopiauiepernambucoaunordestedubresil AT emiliecoudel evaluationdudeveloppementterritorialcommeprocessusdinnovationetdinstitutionnalisationlecasduterritoiredualtosertaodopiauiepernambucoaunordestedubresil AT sergioguilhermedeazevedo evaluationdudeveloppementterritorialcommeprocessusdinnovationetdinstitutionnalisationlecasduterritoiredualtosertaodopiauiepernambucoaunordestedubresil
_version_	1718397774468218880

Évaluation du développement territorial comme processus d'innovation et d'institutionnalisation : le cas du Territoire du Alto Sertão do Piauí e Pernambuco au Nordeste du Brésil

Ejemplares similares